Puzzle Precinct: Detective Training Day

It is training day at the Puzzle Precinct, and someone has stolen the sergeant's birthday cupcakes, for practice.

About this game

It is training day at the Puzzle Precinct. Sergeant Bun has set up a pretend case: their birthday cupcakes have been "stolen" by the Cupcake Bandit. Your job is to find out which of the five cardboard training suspects did it.

The precinct is full of skill stations. Compare fingerprints by their described features. Follow footprints across a grid. Crack a handwriting code. Spot the contradiction in an interview. Work out a time at the Clock Wall. Test samples at the Lab Table using pH numbers. Each solved station that is open for your group gives you an evidence card.

At 3 and 4 players, four stations are open. At 5 and 6, the Clock Wall opens too. At 7 and 8, the Lab Table opens as well. At 3 to 5 players, everyone is on one team, and some people hold more than one job. At 6 to 8 players, you play as two teams.

At the end, your team fills in an elimination grid and names the Bandit, backed up by two evidence cards. Get it right and you graduate.

Expect cardboard suspects with wildly detailed life stories and a sergeant who takes cupcake security very personally.

Paper/HTML locks only: never lock real doors, rooms or people.

The case in one line

The cupcake tray is gone, the lid has a few prints on it, and the cardboard suspects are standing very still in a line. Every solved station gives your team an evidence card. The cards help you cross out suspects until only the Bandit is left.

Good to know

  • Paper/HTML locks only: never lock real doors, rooms or people.
  • The stations, the evidence cards and the elimination grid are paper or screen. Nobody is ever shut in anywhere.
  • Anyone may stop, take a break or leave at any time. A paper cupcake is plenty: do not use real food as a prop if anyone has an allergy.
  • A staged training exercise about pretend-stolen cupcakes. Nobody is in danger and nobody is hurt.
  • The suspects are cardboard cut-outs with silly life stories. The jokes are about the stories, never about how anyone looks.
  • Some puzzles use numbers, times, letters and short word clues. Nothing needs colour, sound or tiny details.
A small station house with party bunting, a giant magnifying glass over a cupcake, and a cupcake box with a fingerprint on it.
Illustration: MysteryPlot team, made with AI assistance

Packet maker

Meet the specialists

Everyone plays a specialist with their own puzzle pieces. Nobody can solve the room alone.

  • Print Examiner

    Looks at tiny swirls the way other people look at clouds.

  • Trail Tracker

    Never takes the long way round, unless a desk is in the way.

  • Handwriting Analyst

    Can read any handwriting, even the handwriting of a very mysterious criminal.

  • Interview Officer

    Listens carefully and always asks one more question.

  • Timekeeper

    Has never been late, and has a stamp to prove it.

  • Lab Technician

    Wears a pretend white coat and a very serious face.

  • Evidence Clerk

    Keeps the grid neat and says 'cleared!' with great joy.

  • Cupcake Guard

    Takes cupcake security more seriously than anyone.

Parts of the room

  • Case Board
  • Print Bench
  • Footprint Hall
  • Note Desk
  • Interview Booth
  • Clock Wall
  • Lab Table

Roles at each player count

Roles at each player count
PlayersSpecialistsTeams
331
441
551
662
772
882

What you need

  • A way to read the packets: print them on Letter or A4, or open them on phones and tablets.
  • One host to run the table. The host guide has no answers, so the host can play too.
  • Player packets (one for each player)
  • Big sheet of paper for the elimination grid
  • Pens or pencils
  • Scrap paper
  • A timer everyone can see, labelled Case Clock
  • A paper cupcake on a plate (optional)
  • Pretend badges for graduation (paper is fine) (optional)

How to play

  1. Choose your player count in the packet maker above and download one packet per player.
  2. The host reads the host guide. Each person gets a specialist packet with their own puzzle pieces.
  3. Work out the puzzles together. Each one needs pieces from more than one person. Every puzzle has three hint levels, and using them costs nothing.
  4. The locks are on paper or on screen only. Never lock a real door, cupboard or person.
  5. Keep the sealed solution file closed until the game is over.

Read the full guide and the printing guide.