The Midnight Radio Hoax

It is 1957, the overnight show is live, and the station's prize microphone has just walked out of its glass case.

About this game

Moonbeam Radio is a one-room station in a sleepy town. Its proudest possession is the Golden Microphone award. Tonight, during the late-night "Insomniac Hour", the award vanishes. The show's host, Velvet Larkspur, is found latched in the record closet, fast asleep on a pile of polka records. And in the empty trophy case? One unpeeled banana.

You and your friends are night-desk reporters for the town paper. Instead of playing suspects, you share the case files between you: the broadcast log, the switchboard notes, the record library and more. Each file holds something the others need. You take turns reading witness statements out loud, then put the night back together minute by minute.

Expect polka emergencies, an astrologer who is very confident about things that already happened, and a lot of people with opinions about that banana.

This is our smallest murder mystery and a great first case for families, couples or a few friends. Nobody gets hurt, and every clue you need is in the files.

The case in one line

At about 12:31 a.m. the Golden Microphone vanishes from its case. Host Velvet Larkspur is found latched in the record closet, asleep on polka records. An unpeeled banana sits in the trophy case.

Good to know

  • Nobody is hurt. The host fell asleep on a pile of records after a very long shift.
  • All people, places, shops and phone numbers are made up. No real stations, call signs or towns.
  • The only wrongdoing is a latched door and a missing prize. Everything is returned at the end.
  • Light comic mischief: a prize goes missing
  • Nobody is hurt: the host just takes an unplanned nap
Flat-vector night cover: a gold microphone, a vintage radio and a banana in front of a small-town skyline, with a clock badge and case tape
Illustration: MysteryPlot team, made with AI assistance

Packet maker

Meet the reporters

Everyone plays a night-desk reporter. The suspects are station staff and townsfolk. Nobody plays them: the host reads their statements out from cards.

  • Marlo Quinby

    Marlo covers radio for the Fiddlebrook Ledger and keeps the Broadcast Log. Marlo knows every programme by heart.

  • Tavi Brantley

    Tavi writes the Ledger's listener column and keeps the Switchboard Notes. Tavi can tell a caller's mood from one hello.

  • Bryn Oakhurst

    Bryn writes about gadgets for the Ledger and holds the Tape Room Sheets. Bryn loves anything with a reel.

  • Arden Lowmoor

    Arden writes the Ledger's town notices and holds the Record Library and Keys. Arden has never lost a key. Arden checks twice.

  • Jordy Ashgrove

    Jordy walks the beat for the Ledger and holds the Street Canvass notes. Jordy knows every milk driver and bus driver in Fiddlebrook.

  • Ellis Dapplemoor

    Ellis writes the Ledger's lost-and-found column and holds the Lost and Found box. Ellis can guess who owns a glove from across the room.

Roles at each player count

Roles at each player count
PlayersReporters played by guestsSuspects read from cards (not played)
226
336
446
556
666

What you need

  • A way to read the packets: print them on Letter or A4, or open them on phones and tablets.
  • One host to run the table. The host guide has no answers, so the host can play too.
  • Reporter packets
  • Name tags
  • Shared card set
  • Sealed final cards in envelopes
  • Accusation cards
  • Pencils and note paper
  • Radio or music for mood (optional)

How to play

  1. Choose your player count in the packet maker above and download one packet per player.
  2. The host reads the host guide, then hands out the packets and name tags.
  3. Play in rounds: arrivals, clue-sharing rounds, the incident, accusations, then the reveal. Everyone holds clues the group needs, so talk to each other.
  4. Keep the sealed solution file closed until the game is over.

Read the full guide and the printing guide.