Curtain Call Catastrophe

Just before the curtain, the headline yodeler takes a spoonful of throat honey and yodels something nobody expected.

About this game

It is Hometown Variety Night at Muddlecombe Hall. The program is packed: one famous yodeler, a magician, a kazoo orchestra, a ventriloquist, a juggler and an off-duty mime who will not stop talking.

The headline act is the famous yodeler Sasha Trillwell. At 7:15 pm, Sasha takes a spoonful of throat honey, just like every show. Tonight the honey has been swapped for chili honey, and the yodel that comes out is a big surprise. Nobody is hurt. The yodeler is fine and only needs a glass of water and a biscuit. The curtain is at 7:30 pm, so the cast must find out who swapped the jar before then.

Every player is an act or a crew member. Most people have a slot in the running order, a costume detail and one thing they saw backstage. Share your sightings, compare timings and work out who swapped the jar. There is an optional 10-second spotlight moment for players who love a spotlight, and passing is fine for those who do not.

Expect a running order that keeps changing all day, a magician who keeps making the wrong things vanish, and a ventriloquist's dummy, Mr. Plank, who has opinions about everything (and those opinions sound a lot like the ventriloquist's).

The case in one line

At 7:15 pm the yodeler opens the jar of throat honey and takes a spoonful, just like every show. It is chili honey, and the yodel that comes out is a big surprise. Nobody is hurt. The yodeler is fine and only needs a glass of water and a biscuit. The curtain is at 7:30 pm, so the cast must find out who swapped the jar before then.

Good to know

  • Nobody is hurt. The yodeler is fine and only needs water and a biscuit.
  • All people, places and the hall are made up. No real towns, shows, brands or people.
  • Everything is paper cards or phone pages. If you serve tea, snacks or honey, check for allergies first. Real chili honey is not part of the game.
  • Comic mischief: a jar of throat honey is swapped for chili honey before the show
  • Nobody is hurt. The yodeler is fine and only needs a glass of water and a biscuit
  • No alcohol, no weapons and nobody bets money on anything
Flat-vector theatre cover: a honey jar with a puff of flame, a kazoo and music notes in a backstage room, with a clock badge and case tape
Illustration: MysteryPlot team, made with AI assistance

Packet maker

Meet the cast

Everyone plays a character. More characters join as your group grows; at smaller numbers the missing ones appear on cards the host reads out.

  • Sasha Trillwell

    Sasha Trillwell is the headline yodeler. Sasha has opened and closed Hometown Variety Night for 20 years.

    Joins from 10 players.

  • Quinn Parpwell

    Quinn Parpwell conducts the Muddlecombe Kazoo Orchestra. The band is small, loyal and very, very soft.

    Joins from 10 players.

  • Devon Flourish

    Devon Flourish is the magician. Devon makes scarves, coins and sometimes the wrong thing vanish.

    Joins from 10 players.

  • Tatum Voxley

    Tatum Voxley is the ventriloquist. Tatum's partner is a wooden dummy called Mr. Plank, who has a lot to say.

    Joins from 10 players.

  • Jamie Standby

    Jamie Standby is the understudy. Jamie knows every song, every joke and every step.

    Joins from 10 players.

  • Lindy Cuesby

    Lindy Cuesby is the stage manager. Lindy has a clipboard, a headset and a whistle.

    Joins from 10 players.

  • Gray Clankworth

    Gray Clankworth looks after the hall. Gray fixes the lights, the taps and the squeaky stage.

    Joins from 10 players.

  • Oakley Threadwell

    Oakley Threadwell runs the wardrobe. Oakley sews, pins and sparkles everyone for the stage.

    Joins from 10 players.

  • Reed Hummerton

    Reed Hummerton plays first kazoo and keeps the band in line.

    Joins from 10 players.

  • Corey Hushmore

    Corey Hushmore is the hall's off-duty mime. Corey is not performing tonight, and Corey is still talking.

    Joins from 10 players.

  • Frankie Gluepot

    Frankie Gluepot is the prop master. Frankie can find a missing prop in the dark.

    Joins from 11 players.

  • Piper Dropwell

    Piper Dropwell is the juggler. Piper juggles soft clubs, scarves and one very patient rubber chicken.

    Joins from 12 players.

  • Morgan Tootsworth

    Morgan Tootsworth plays second kazoo and lights up whenever the band plays.

    Joins from 13 players.

  • Robin Buzzbee

    Robin Buzzbee plays third kazoo and carries the band's music stands.

    Joins from 14 players.

  • Nova Dialwright

    Nova Dialwright runs the sound desk. Nova can make a whisper sound like a thunderclap.

    Joins from 15 players.

  • Ari Spotlowe

    Ari Spotlowe runs the lights. Ari can find anyone in the dark with one beam.

    Joins from 16 players.

  • Dana Stubbsworth

    Dana Stubbsworth runs the box office and tears every ticket exactly in half.

    Joins from 17 players.

  • Sam Aislewood

    Sam Aislewood is the head usher. Sam knows every seat and every squeak.

    Joins from 18 players.

  • Blake Crumpley

    Blake Crumpley runs the Tea Hatch. Blake pours tea, counts scones and knows everyone's order.

    Joins from 19 players.

  • Kai Bellowes

    Kai Bellowes is the emcee, the one who announces the acts. Kai welcomes the crowd, reads the running order and tells jokes between acts.

    Joins from 20 players.

Roles at each player count

Roles at each player count
PlayersCharacters played by guestsCharacters read from cardsSuspects in all
10101020
1111920
1212820
1313720
1414620
1515520
1616420
1717320
1818220
1919120
2020020

What you need

  • A way to read the packets: print them on Letter or A4, or open them on phones and tablets.
  • One host to run the table. The host guide has no answers, so the host can play too.
  • Player packets
  • Name tags
  • Shared card set
  • Sealed final cards in envelopes
  • Accusation cards
  • Pencils and scrap paper
  • Bedsheet for a curtain (optional)
  • Toy rubber chicken (optional)
  • Tea, water and biscuits for the reveal (optional)

How to play

  1. Choose your player count in the packet maker above and download one packet per player.
  2. The host reads the host guide, then hands out the packets and name tags.
  3. Play in rounds: arrivals, clue-sharing rounds, the incident, accusations, then the reveal. Everyone holds clues the group needs, so talk to each other.
  4. Keep the sealed solution file closed until the game is over.

Read the full guide and the printing guide.