Murder mystery games for 8 to 10 players

Eight murder mystery games fit 8 to 10 players: Who Pinched Sir Pebblebottom?, The Last Strawberry on Mars, The Parrot Saw Everything, The Telescope Thief of Mount Wobble, Camp Wannagetaway, The Sheriff's Missing Moustache, Curtain Call Catastrophe, The Crown of Little Pickleberg.

Eight to ten players is the classic murder mystery party size. The room has energy, people split into small huddles to trade secrets, and the accusation round gets loud in a good way.

Games that fit 8 to 10 players

At each player count

Roles and play time by player count
PlayersGameRoles in playPlay time
8Who Pinched Sir Pebblebottom?8 suspects90 to 120 minutes
8The Last Strawberry on Mars10 suspects105 to 135 minutes
8The Parrot Saw Everything12 suspects120 to 150 minutes
8The Telescope Thief of Mount Wobble14 suspects105 to 135 minutes
8Camp Wannagetaway16 suspects120 to 150 minutes
8The Sheriff's Missing Moustache20 suspects110 to 150 minutes
8The Crown of Little Pickleberg16 suspects120 to 150 minutes
9The Last Strawberry on Mars10 suspects105 to 135 minutes
9The Parrot Saw Everything12 suspects120 to 150 minutes
9The Telescope Thief of Mount Wobble14 suspects105 to 135 minutes
9Camp Wannagetaway16 suspects120 to 150 minutes
9The Sheriff's Missing Moustache20 suspects110 to 150 minutes
9The Crown of Little Pickleberg16 suspects120 to 150 minutes
10The Last Strawberry on Mars10 suspects105 to 135 minutes
10The Parrot Saw Everything12 suspects120 to 150 minutes
10The Telescope Thief of Mount Wobble14 suspects105 to 135 minutes
10Camp Wannagetaway16 suspects120 to 150 minutes
10The Sheriff's Missing Moustache20 suspects110 to 150 minutes
10Curtain Call Catastrophe20 suspects120 to 150 minutes
10The Crown of Little Pickleberg16 suspects120 to 150 minutes

The packet maker on each game page lists the exact pages to print for your player count.

Hosting advice for 8 to 10 players

  • Use a ringing signal. A bell, a spoon on a glass or a whistle helps you start and end rounds without shouting.
  • Expect huddles. Players will split into groups of two or three. That is good. Walk around and remind people to share what they learn.
  • Make a clue wall. Pin shared evidence cards to a wall or lay them on a side table so huddles can check them.
  • Plan the reveal seating. Bring everyone into a circle for accusations so each person can be heard.
  • Time is a bit longer. Allow about 2 to 2.5 hours with snacks. If you are short on time, check whether the game has a shorter mode.

What this adds

Eight to ten players gives the full party feel, with huddles, side deals and a properly noisy accusation round.

Other group sizes

All murder mystery games or the planner.