The Sheriff's Missing Moustache

On contest day, the 11-time champion wakes from a 2:00 to 2:30 pm nap with exactly half a moustache.

About this game

Welcome to Dry Biscuit, a dusty frontier town that takes one thing very seriously: the Magnificent Moustache Contest. This is its 50th year. There is even a fake-moustache category, so anyone can enter.

Sheriff "Whiskers" has won 11 times in a row. On contest day, they wake from their usual 2:00 to 2:30 pm nap in the jailhouse and look in the mirror. Half the famous moustache is gone. Not trimmed. Gone. The town holds an inquiry at 4:30 pm. The contest starts at 6:00 pm.

The sheriff is played by one of your guests, and they are investigating their own upper lip. Everyone else is a townsperson: the barber, the deputy, the tonic seller, the teacher, the stagecoach clerk, the newspaper editor, the cowpoke poet and many more. Each player saw someone pass the jail window at a certain time. At the start, contest entrants tell a moustache origin story. Some of those stories are even true.

Expect tumbleweeds with names, a saloon that serves only sarsaparilla, a tonic seller with a potion for everything, and contest rules longer than the town's history.

Scales from a busy dinner to a whole-town party of 20.

The case in one line

At 2:30 pm the sheriff wakes from the nap and looks in the mirror. Half of the famous moustache is gone. The other half is fine. Nobody is hurt, and no blades were used. The contest starts at 6:00 pm, so the town must find out who did it before then.

Good to know

  • Nobody is hurt. The moustache is only wiped away and it will grow back.
  • All people, places and the town of Dry Biscuit are made up. No real towns, brands or people.
  • Everything is paper cards or phone pages. If you serve sarsaparilla, root beer or snacks, check for allergies first. Paper moustaches on sticks are for wearing, not for chewing.
  • Comic mischief: half of the sheriff's moustache goes missing during a nap
  • Nobody is hurt. No blades are used and the moustache will grow back
  • The saloon serves sarsaparilla only, and nobody bets money on anything
Flat-vector frontier cover: a cactus with a tumbleweed, a tin star and half a moustache drawn in dashes, with a magnifier badge and case tape
Illustration: MysteryPlot team, made with AI assistance

Packet maker

Meet the cast

Everyone plays a character. More characters join as your group grows; at smaller numbers the missing ones appear on cards the host reads out.

  • Hattie Bramblecote

    Hattie Bramblecote, known as Whiskers, is the sheriff of Dry Biscuit. They have won the moustache contest 11 times in a row.

    Joins from 8 players.

  • Jesse Wade

    Jesse Wade is the deputy of Dry Biscuit. Jesse keeps the jail tidy and carries a clipboard everywhere.

    Joins from 8 players.

  • Dell Snipwell

    Dell Snipwell runs the barber shop. Dell sells haircuts, shaves and a new peppermint cream.

    Joins from 8 players.

  • Mercy Bottlebrush

    Mercy Bottlebrush sells tonics from a painted wagon. Every tonic cures at least three things.

    Joins from 8 players.

  • Ainsley Crabtree

    Ainsley Crabtree teaches at the Dry Biscuit schoolhouse. Ainsley has entered a fake moustache in the contest.

    Joins from 8 players.

  • Opal Bramblecote

    Opal Bramblecote is the sheriff's sibling. Opal has watched the sheriff win 11 contests in a row.

    Joins from 8 players.

  • Sutton Axlebury

    Sutton Axlebury runs the stage stop and keeps very neat records.

    Joins from 8 players.

  • Rowan Saddlestone

    Rowan Saddlestone keeps the saloon. Rowan serves sarsaparilla only, with one refill each.

    Joins from 8 players.

  • Garnet Hammerley

    Garnet Hammerley is the town blacksmith. Garnet makes horseshoes, gates and very loud noises.

    Joins from 9 players.

  • Hollis Dimebury

    Hollis Dimebury runs the Dry Biscuit bank. Hollis counts everything twice, even sarsaparilla.

    Joins from 10 players.

  • Blythe Printwell

    Blythe Printwell edits the Dry Biscuit Gazette. The Gazette comes out whenever Blythe is ready.

    Joins from 11 players.

  • Skye Oatley

    Skye Oatley is the town cowpoke poet. Skye rhymes with everything, even tumbleweeds.

    Joins from 12 players.

  • Teddy Glassplate

    Teddy Glassplate takes the town's pictures. The camera is big, old and very slow.

    Joins from 13 players.

  • Rudy Haywire

    Rudy Haywire looks after the town ponies at the livery. Rudy has named every pony after a moustache.

    Joins from 14 players.

  • Maple Kettleby

    Maple Kettleby cooks from a chuck wagon. Maple serves beans, bread and big opinions.

    Joins from 15 players.

  • Lowell Featherbed

    Lowell Featherbed runs the Dry Biscuit boarding house. Lowell makes the softest beds in the county.

    Joins from 16 players.

  • Merritt Gavelby

    Merritt Gavelby is the chief judge. Merritt has written 212 rules, and some of them have sub-rules.

    Joins from 17 players.

  • Alva Wirehouse

    Alva Wirehouse runs the telegraph office. Alva sends the news in dots and dashes.

    Joins from 18 players.

  • Jules Pilbury

    Jules Pilbury is the town doctor. Jules mends cuts, splinters and the odd case of hiccups.

    Joins from 19 players.

  • Pike Gravelly

    Pike Gravelly is the town crier. Pike winds the town clock and shouts the news.

    Joins from 20 players.

Roles at each player count

Roles at each player count
PlayersCharacters played by guestsCharacters read from cardsSuspects in all
881220
991120
10101020
1111920
1212820
1313720
1414620
1515520
1616420
1717320
1818220
1919120
2020020

What you need

  • A way to read the packets: print them on Letter or A4, or open them on phones and tablets.
  • One host to run the table. The host guide has no answers, so the host can play too.
  • Player packets
  • Name tags
  • Shared card set
  • Sealed final cards in envelopes
  • Accusation cards
  • Pencils and scrap paper
  • Paper moustaches on sticks (optional)
  • Sarsaparilla or root beer for the reveal (optional)

How to play

  1. Choose your player count in the packet maker above and download one packet per player.
  2. The host reads the host guide, then hands out the packets and name tags.
  3. Play in rounds: arrivals, clue-sharing rounds, the incident, accusations, then the reveal. Everyone holds clues the group needs, so talk to each other.
  4. Keep the sealed solution file closed until the game is over.

Read the full guide and the printing guide.