Who Pinched Sir Pebblebottom?

The champion gnome is gone, and the ransom note is made of seed packets.

About this game

It is awards night at the Thistlewick Allotment Society. An allotment is a small plot where neighbours grow vegetables. The lanterns are lit in the greenhouse. Everyone is here: the proud gardeners, the bee people and the pumpkin people. Admiral Shellsworth is here too. The Admiral is a tortoise, and the head of security.

During the moonlight pumpkin tour, Sir Reginald Pebblebottom vanishes from his plinth, the stand he sits on. A very silly ransom note, made of letters cut from seed packets, says the Golden Trowel must go "to the compost heap". Nobody is hurt.

Each player has a secret and a story to tell. Most secrets are about vegetables. Share what you know, catch the fib, and name the gnome-napper before the trophy goes on the compost.

Expect extremely serious vegetable feuds, very polite seed swaps that are not polite at all, and a security chief who has never once rushed.

The case in one line

During the moonlight pumpkin tour, Sir Reginald Pebblebottom, the champion garden gnome, vanishes from his plinth, the stand he sits on. A ransom note made of seed-packet letters says the Golden Trowel must go 'to the compost heap'. Nobody is hurt.

Good to know

  • Nobody is hurt. The only thing at risk is a garden gnome's pride.
  • All people, places, clubs and awards are made up. No real shows, brands or garden societies.
  • Everything is paper cards. If you put a real gnome on the table, keep it away from pranksters.
  • Comic mischief: a garden gnome goes missing
  • Nobody is hurt. The only thing at stake is a gnome's pride
Flat-vector dusk cover: a garden gnome with a pointed hat beside a big pumpkin on rolling hills, with a magnifier badge and case tape
Illustration: MysteryPlot team, made with AI assistance

Packet maker

Meet the cast

Everyone plays a character. More characters join as your group grows; at smaller numbers the missing ones appear on cards the host reads out.

  • Fern Oduya

    Fern is the Society secretary. Fern keeps the minutes, the stamps and a very tidy desk. Fern has never lost a pencil.

    Joins from 3 players.

  • Basil Thorne-Ashby

    Basil is the Society president. Basil reads out the awards and loves a loud bullhorn.

    Joins from 3 players.

  • Juniper Kwan

    Juniper keeps the Society's bees. Juniper names every bee and hums while working.

    Joins from 3 players.

  • Teasel Wetherby

    Teasel has won Biggest Pumpkin seven years in a row. Teasel guides the moonlight pumpkin tour.

    Joins from 4 players.

  • Clem Dunmore

    Clem runs the slug patrol. Clem walks the beds at night with a torch and a tiny notebook.

    Joins from 5 players.

  • Quill Haverstock

    Quill is treasurer of the Tool Shed fund. Quill counts every seed packet, spade and free draw ticket.

    Joins from 6 players.

  • Sorrel Applegarth

    Sorrel is the youngest member and the Society's lantern bearer. Sorrel keeps the Tool Shed tidy.

    Joins from 7 players.

  • Linden Marchbanks

    Linden is the visiting judge from the next county. Linden scores everything with a gold pen.

    Joins from 8 players.

Roles at each player count

Roles at each player count
PlayersCharacters played by guestsCharacters read from cardsSuspects in all
3358
4448
5538
6628
7718
8808

What you need

  • A way to read the packets: print them on Letter or A4, or open them on phones and tablets.
  • One host to run the table. The host guide has no answers, so the host can play too.
  • Player packets
  • Name tags
  • Shared card set
  • Sealed final cards in envelopes
  • Accusation cards
  • Pencils and scrap paper
  • Fairy lights or battery lanterns (optional)
  • Toy gnome or gnome drawing for the plinth (optional)
  • Cordial or sarsaparilla and cups (optional)

How to play

  1. Choose your player count in the packet maker above and download one packet per player.
  2. The host reads the host guide, then hands out the packets and name tags.
  3. Play in rounds: arrivals, clue-sharing rounds, the incident, accusations, then the reveal. Everyone holds clues the group needs, so talk to each other.
  4. Keep the sealed solution file closed until the game is over.

Read the full guide and the printing guide.